INJURED ON THE VIKING SKY CRUISE SHIP IN STORM OFF OF NORWAY?
(IF YOU THINK THE STORM AND RESCUE WAS BAD WAIT UNTIL YOU LEARN HOW DIFFICULT IT IS TO SUE VIKING!)
The recent headlines have been overflowing with pictures, videos, tweets and news reports about the crippled Viking Sky caught in a vicious storm off of the coast of Norway. On Monday, Norway’s government announced an investigation into why the ship had left port in the first place despite storm warnings. There are also questions surrounding why three of the ship’s four engines lost power and what was done to restart those engines after the seas calmed. With nine people from the cruise reported to have been hospitalized on Monday, including one in critical condition, lawsuits against Viking seem likely. Nevertheless, such prospective plaintiffs need to understand and appreciate that the quest to obtain compensation for the damages and injuries they have suffered will not be “clear sailing”.
One must first start by reviewing the terms and conditions of Viking River Cruises, I nc.’s Ticket Booking And Sale Contract. It provides, in part:
So Viking claims it isn’t even the carrier, just a sales and marketing agent and you would have to look to your specific ticket contract to see who the carrier was for the Viking Sky. Reviewing the Passenger Ticket Contract (“PTC”), you learn that the “Carrier” is either: either Viking River Tours LTD, Viking Ocean Cruises LTD , Viking Ocean Cruises II LTD, or Viking Cruises USA LTD, each a corporation organized and existing in current good standing pursuant to the laws of Bermuda. The PTC goes on to state:
a. We shall not be liable for such death, injury, illness, damage, delay, loss or detriment caused by Act of God, war or warlike operations, civil commotions, labor trouble, interference by Authorities, perils of the sea, lurching of the vessel, or any cause beyond our control, fire, thefts or any other crime, errors in the navigation or management of the Ship or defect in or unseaworthiness of hull, machinery, appurtenances, equipment, furnishing or supplies of the Ship, fault or neglect of pilot, tugs, agents or independent contractors such as Ship’s physician, to you or other persons on board not in our employ or any other cause of whatsoever nature except and unless it is proven that such death, injury, illness, damage, delay or loss resulted from our act or omission committed during the course of the carriage and due to our fault or neglect or that of any of our servants or agents acting within the scope of their employment, and in that event our liability therefore shall not exceed those limitations provided by the applicable law described below, or in any further revisions, protocols and/ or amendments thereto as shall become applicable.
Essentially, it doesn’t matter what we do wrong – we are not liable beyond the limitations of liability that we have agreed to. Those limitations of liability that would apply to the Viking Sky’s ill-fated journey would be:
1. Ocean cruises (E.U. Member State Port): On ocean cruise tours which neither embark, disembark nor call at any U.S. port and where the ocean cruise tour embarks or disembarks in the port of any E.U. Member State, our responsibility as the Carrier for death, injury, illness, damage, delay or other loss to person or property of any kind suffered by you or any of the other Passengers in your party shall, in the first instance, be governed by E.U. Regulation 392/2009. Unless the loss or damage was caused by a shipping incident, which is defined as a shipwreck, capsizing, collision or stranding of the ship, explosion or fire in the ship, or defect in the ship (as defined by the Regulation), Carrier’s liability is limited to no more than 400,000 Special Drawing Rights (“SDR”) per passenger, (approximately U.S. $564,000, which fluctuates depending on the daily exchange rate as published by the International Monetary Fund at http://www.imf.org/external/np/fin/data/rms_sdrv.aspx) if the passenger proves that the incident was a result of Carrier’s fault or neglect. If the loss or damage was caused by a shipping incident, Carrier’s liability is limited to no more than 250,000 SDRs per passenger (approximately U.S. $352,000, which fluctuates depending on the daily exchange rate for SDRs as published by the International Monetary Fund at http://www.imf.org/external/np/ fin/data/rms_sdrv.aspx). Compensation for loss caused by a shipping incident can increase to a maximum of 400,000 SDRs per passenger unless Carrier proves that the shipping incident occurred without Carrier’s fault or neglect. Shipping incidents do not include acts of war, hostilities, civil war, insurrection, natural disasters, or intentional acts or omissions of third parties. In cases where the loss or damage was caused in connection with war or terrorism, Carrier’s liability for any personal injury or death (whether occurring during a shipping incident or a non-shipping incident) is limited to the lower of 250,000 SDRs per passenger or 340 million SDRs per ship per incident. Punitive damages are not recoverable for cruises covered by EU Regulation 392/2009. A copy of EU Regulation 392/2009 is available at http://eur-lex. europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?ur i=OJ:L:2009:131:0024:0046:EN:PDF. In addition, our liability as Carrier will be governed by those other and further limitations of liability set forth in the statutory maritime and general laws of Switzerland without regard to its conflict of laws provisions, as the law governing these Passenger Ticket Contract Terms and Conditions. (For individual residents of Quebec, please see the Canadian Addendum at the end of this agreement.) You agree that the Carrier’s liability for loss or damage to baggage or personal property is limited under all circumstances to the provisions and amounts of the Athens Convention Relating to the Carriage of Passengers and Their Luggage by Sea of 1974 as well as the Protocol of 2002 to the Athens Convention. Under the Athens Convention and 2002 Protocol the liability of the Carrier for the loss of or damage to Cabin Baggage will not exceed 2,250 SDRs per Passenger; the liability of the Carrier for the loss of or damage to Other Baggage will not exceed 3,375 SDRs per Passenger. The current U.S. Dollar equivalent of SDRs may be found at www.imf.org. A copy of the Athens Convention and 2002 Protocol will be provided by Carrier upon written request.
Viking will likely claim that this was a “shipping incident” and that it had no fault or neglect, thus limitingdamages to approximately $352,000. If fault is proved, the damage limitation would be increased to approximately $564,000.
The PTC also limits where suit may be brought, what law applies and the time limit for bringing suit. In that regard, the PTC states:
WHERE SUIT MUST BE BROUGHT:
ANY DISPUTE ARISING OUT OF OR IN CONNECTION WITH THESE PASSENGER TICKET CONTRACT TERMS AND CONDITIONS SHALL BE DETERMINED BY THE CIVIL COURT OF THE CANTON OF BASEL-STADT [ZIVILGERICHT BASEL-STADT], THE JURISDICTION TO WHICH WE, AS THE CARRIER, AND YOU HEREBY EXCLUSIVELY SUBMIT OURSELVES. IF ANY ACTION IS INITIATED IN ANY COURT OTHER THAN THE COURTS IN BASEL SWITZERLAND, OTHER THAN THOSE OF MONTREAL IN THE CASE OF AN INDIVIDUAL RESIDENT OF QUEBEC, WE, AS THE CARRIER, AND YOU HEREBY AGREE TO THE IMMEDIATE DISMISSAL OR TRANSFER OF SAID ACTION TO THE COURTS OF BASEL, SWITZERLAND.
WHAT LAW APPLIES:
All questions arising on these Passenger Ticket Contract Terms and Conditions solely in respect of the limitation of liability shall be decided according to the described Conventions and Protocols and the other and further laws cited at Article 10 hereof, including the statutory, maritime and general laws of Switzerland. (See Canadian Addendum for residents of Quebec.) The law governing all other aspects of these Passenger Ticket Contract Terms and Conditions is stipulated and agreed to be the statutory and general law of Switzerland, with references to which these Passenger Ticket Contract Terms and Conditions is made.
WHEN CLAIM NOTICE MUST BE GIVEN AND SUIT MUST BE BROUGHT:
NO SUIT SHALL BE MAINTAINED AGAINST US FOR DELAY, DETENTION, PERSONAL INJURY, ILLNESS OR DEATH OF THE PASSENGER UNLESS WRITTEN NOTICE OF THE CLAIM WITH FULL PARTICULARS BE DELIVERED TO US OR VIKING RIVER CRUISES, INC. WITHIN SIX (6) MONTHS FROM THE DAY WHEN SUCH DELAY, DETENTION, PERSONAL INJURY, ILLNESS OR DEATH OF THE PASSENGER OCCURRED; AND IN NO EVENT SHALL ANY SUIT FOR ANY CAUSE AGAINST US WITH RESPECT TO DELAY, DETENTION, PERSONAL INJURY, ILLNESS OR DEATH BE MAINTAINABLE, UNLESS SUIT SHALL BE COMMENCED WITHIN ONE (1) YEAR FROM THE DAY WHEN THE DELAY, DETENTION, PERSONAL INJURY, ILLNESS OR DEATH OF THE PASSENGER OCCURRED.
So you would have six (6) months to put Viking on notice of your claim by sending it a detailed demand or notice letter and then, absent a settlement being reached before then, you would have to bring suit in Switzerland, THE CANTON OF BASEL-STADT [ZIVILGERICHT BASEL-STADT] within one (1) year.
This blog post will not get into the intricacies of Swiss Maritime Law, however as one can now appreciate, making and collecting on a personal injury claim against Viking in both complex and involved with many obstacles and limitations.
Should you or a loved one have been injured as a result of the recent incident involving the Viking Sky or on any cruise ship vacation, the experienced maritime/cruise ship injury lawyers at Charlip Law Group, LC are ready to assist you.