What is a Strategic Foreclosure in Florida?

Last updated on: July 4, 2023

Facing the possibility of foreclosure can be an overwhelming experience for homeowners in Florida. With the complexities of the legal system and financial implications involved, it’s crucial to understand the options available. One such option gaining attention is strategic foreclosure. In this article, we will delve into the concept of strategic foreclosure in Florida, examining its meaning, implications, and potential benefits for homeowners in distress.

Navigating the foreclosure process in Florida can be challenging, but enlisting the services of an experienced Florida foreclosure lawyer can provide invaluable assistance. A skilled lawyer specializing in foreclosure law can guide homeowners through the intricacies of deciding on the financial sense of a foreclosure, ensuring their rights are protected every step of the way. At Charlip Law Group, our experienced Florida foreclosure attorneys may be able to help homeowners understand mortgage lenders’ notice before foreclosure, negotiate with lenders, and explore alternatives to foreclosure. With our wide experience in the field, our team may be able to provide personalized advice and representation, empowering homeowners to make informed decisions that best suit their unique circumstances. Contact us today at (305) 354-9313 to schedule a consultation.

Foreclosure Attorney David H. Charlip Defines Strategic Foreclosure in Florida

Strategic foreclosure is a deliberate decision by a homeowner to stop making mortgage payments on their property and allow the home to enter the foreclosure process, despite having the financial ability to continue making payments. This is different from a traditional foreclosure, which typically results from a homeowner’s inability to make their mortgage payments due to financial hardship.

Homeowners often decide on a strategic foreclosure when the outstanding mortgage balance is greater than the current value of the property. By allowing the home to go into foreclosure, they effectively walk away from the debt and start anew. However, this decision can have long-lasting consequences for the homeowner’s credit and financial future.

Strategic Foreclosure vs. Traditional Foreclosure

The primary distinction between strategic and traditional foreclosure lies in the motivation and circumstances surrounding the decision to let a property enter foreclosure. While a traditional foreclosure is typically the result of financial hardship that makes continued mortgage payments impossible for the homeowner, a strategic foreclosure is a deliberate choice made by a financially capable homeowner.

In a traditional foreclosure, the lender repossesses the property when the homeowner defaults on the mortgage payments. In a strategic foreclosure, the homeowner essentially chooses to default by stopping payments, despite their ability to continue making payments.

Legal and Ethical Considerations

The decision to pursue a strategic foreclosure can raise legal and ethical concerns.

From a legal standpoint, homeowners should be aware that some states have recourse laws, allowing lenders to seek a deficiency judgment against the homeowner for the remaining mortgage balance after the foreclosure sale. This could result in the homeowner still being responsible for covering a portion of the debt, even after the foreclosure process is complete.

Ethically, a strategic foreclosure can be seen as a violation of the mortgage contract, which stipulates that the homeowner will repay the loan in full. By not honoring this agreement, the homeowner may be perceived as abandoning their financial obligations, potentially impacting their credibility for future transactions.

Furthermore, strategic foreclosure can contribute to a community’s economic decline, as foreclosed properties may drive down local property values. This decline can make it more challenging for neighboring homeowners to sell their properties and may lead to a higher number of foreclosures in the area, further exacerbating the negative impact on the community.

In summary, understanding strategic foreclosure is essential for homeowners and other parties involved in the decision-making process. Considering the long-lasting effects and potential consequences of such a decision, it is crucial for those involved to gather information, consult with experts, and carefully weigh the options before determining the best course of action.

Florida foreclosure lawyer

Florida Foreclosure Laws

Florida foreclosure laws are important to understand for any homeowner or potential property buyer in the state. These laws dictate the process by which a lender can repossess a borrower’s property if they default on their mortgage loan. This section will provide an overview of both processes, as well as the required notifications and timeline for foreclosure and deficiency judgments in Florida.

Judicial Foreclosure Process

In Florida, judicial foreclosure is the only method of the foreclosure process. This process involves the lender filing a lawsuit with the court to obtain a final judgment of foreclosure. The lender must first file a complaint, which includes information about the borrower, the property, and the loan.

Upon receiving the complaint, the borrower has 20 days to file an answer, which may include any applicable defenses against the foreclosure. If the borrower fails to respond within the given timeframe, the lender may request a default judgment. If the borrower does respond with an answer, the case will proceed to a trial or summary judgment, depending on the specific circumstances.

Once a final judgment is entered in favor of the lender, the court will typically issue a writ of execution directing the local sheriff’s office to sell the property at a public auction. The highest bidder at the auction, which may include the lender themselves, will become the new owner of the property. In some cases, the borrower may have a right to redeem the property by paying the full outstanding balance and any fees or costs before the auction.

Non-Judicial Foreclosure Process

Florida does not typically allow for non-judicial foreclosures, as there is no specific statute authorizing this process. However, in certain cases involving condominiums or homeowner associations, non-judicial foreclosure by a lienholder other than the mortgage lender may be possible. In these cases, the process is generally carried out through a power of sale clause in the lien, subject to certain notice and procedural requirements.

It should be noted that non-judicial foreclosure is not allowed in Florida, and the following sections will focus primarily on judicial foreclosure.

Required Notifications and Timeline

Under Florida law, the lender must comply with several notification requirements during the foreclosure process. The first requirement is the notice of default, which must be sent to the borrower at least 30 days before filing the foreclosure complaint. This notice informs the borrower of their loan default and the lender’s intention to foreclose if the default is not cured within the specified timeframe.

Once the foreclosure complaint is filed, the lender must serve the complaint and a summons to the borrower. The borrower then has 20 days to respond with an answer, as previously mentioned.

If the foreclosure proceeds to a public auction, the lender must publish a notice of sale in a local newspaper for at least two consecutive weeks, with the final publication being at least five days before the sale date. Additionally, the notice of sale must be posted at the courthouse where the foreclosure is taking place and at the subject property.

While the exact timeline for a Florida foreclosure can vary depending on the individual case, the entire process typically takes anywhere from six months to over a year from the initial notice of default to the completion of the foreclosure sale.

Deficiency Judgments in Florida

After a foreclosure sale, the lender may seek a deficiency judgment against the borrower if the sale price of the property is less than the outstanding balance of the mortgage loan. In Florida, the lender has one year from the date of the foreclosure sale to file a motion for a deficiency judgment.

The amount of the deficiency judgment will be determined by the court, taking into consideration the fair market value of the property at the time of the foreclosure sale and the total outstanding debt, including principal, interest, and any applicable fees or costs.

It’s important to note that Florida has specific exemptions and protections for homestead properties, which can prevent or limit deficiency judgments in some cases. Additionally, borrowers may be able to negotiate a waiver of the deficiency as part of a short sale or deed in lieu of a foreclosure agreement with their lender.

Financial Consequences of Strategic Foreclosure

While a strategic foreclosure may seem appealing in some circumstances, it is still important to consider the potential repercussions of intentionally defaulting on your mortgage. Some consequences of a strategic foreclosure can include:

Impact on Credit Score

A homeowner can explore a strategic foreclosure when their property’s current market value is less than the outstanding balance on the loan. Though it is financially advantageous in some cases, it also brings with it a range of adverse financial consequences, particularly on the borrower’s credit score.

When a borrower undergoes foreclosure, the lender reports the default to the credit bureaus, resulting in a significant negative impact on the borrower’s credit score. A foreclosure can lower the borrower’s credit score by as much as 200-300 points, depending on the circumstances and the individual’s credit history. This negative mark remains on the credit report for up to seven years, making it difficult for the borrower to secure new credit or loans during this period.

Furthermore, lenders and potential creditors may view a foreclosure unfavorably, signaling financial irresponsibility and increasing the perception of risk associated with lending to that individual. As a result, borrowers who have undergone strategic foreclosure may face higher interest rates or be rejected altogether when attempting to obtain new credit.

Tax Implications

In addition to the impact on credit scores, strategic foreclosures can also carry tax implications for borrowers. As a result of the Mortgage Forgiveness Debt Relief Act of 2007, borrowers can exclude debt forgiven in a foreclosure-related to their primary residence from their taxable income. However, this exclusion does not extend to strategic foreclosures involving investment properties or vacation homes.

In situations where the exclusion does not apply, the forgiven debt is treated as taxable income. Borrowers will receive a 1099-C form from their lender, which reports the amount of canceled debt they must report to the IRS. This can lead to a significant tax liability, especially for borrowers with high loan balances and marginal tax rates.

Credit and Loan Eligibility After Foreclosure

The impact of a strategic foreclosure on an individual’s credit score can significantly impact their ability to secure new credit and loan opportunities in the future. For example, borrowers who have undergone foreclosure may find it difficult or impossible to obtain a new mortgage loan, depending on the specific underwriting guidelines of the relevant lending institution.

Even after the waiting period has passed, borrowers who have experienced foreclosure may still face higher interest rates or more stringent loan requirements when attempting to secure a new mortgage or other credit products.

Financial Consequences of Strategic Foreclosure Details
Impact on Credit Score Lowers credit score by 200-300 points, leaving a negative mark for up to 7 years. Difficult to secure new credit or loans. Higher interest rates or rejection when applying for new credit.
Tax Implications Primary residence foreclosure debt excluded from taxable income under the Mortgage Forgiveness Debt Relief Act of 2007. Exclusion doesn’t apply to strategic foreclosures involving investment properties or vacation homes. Strategic foreclosure debt treated as taxable income, leading to a significant tax liability.
Credit and Loan Eligibility Difficulty obtaining new mortgage loan. Higher interest rates or more stringent loan requirements even after the waiting period.

Preparing for the Foreclosure Process

Once you have consulted with a real estate attorney and weighed the risks and benefits, it’s time to prepare for the foreclosure process. Some important steps include:

Notice of Default

Once you miss a certain number of payments, the lender will take legal action by filing a complaint, initiating the foreclosure process in Florida. Subsequently, you will receive a Notice of Default, which signifies that you have defaulted on your mortgage agreement, and the foreclosure process has officially commenced. It is crucial to seek the assistance of an attorney at this stage because failing to do so will likely result in losing your home within six months.

Acceptance and Review of Summons and Complaint

When the lender initiates a lawsuit against you due to defaulting on mortgage payments, they will submit a summons and complaint along with a lis pendens. “Lis pendens” is a Latin term meaning “pending litigation.” These documents indicate that the lender has filed a lawsuit against you based on the defaulted mortgage and intends to reclaim your home. After filing these documents with the county courthouse, they become part of the public record. 

Usually, a county sheriff will personally deliver the summons and complaint to you. While many individuals try to avoid receiving these documents, it is recommended not to do so. If the lender suspects you are evading service, they may resort to alternative methods, such as publishing the complaint in the local newspaper. Upon receiving the summons and complaint, it is crucial to thoroughly read these documents as they outline your rights and responsibilities. Typically, the process of filing the summons and complaint takes between 10 and 20 days.

Filing Your Response

Once you receive the summons and complaint, you have a 20-day window to prepare and file a response. Filing a response is a critical step in the Florida foreclosure process. Failing to file an official response may deprive you of the opportunity to present your case and defenses before a judge, potentially resulting in a final judgment against you and the loss of your home.

The response serves as your initial chance to explain your defenses, such as any violations of your rights by the lender throughout the mortgage or foreclosure process. Many homeowners mistakenly believe that they have no options once a summons and complaint are filed. However, filing a response can help you secure a preliminary hearing, significantly increasing your chances of retaining ownership of your home.

Attendance at Hearings

After filing your response, the courts will schedule a preliminary hearing. During this hearing, you will have the opportunity to present your defenses and present your side of the story. If the judge finds your response compelling and considers it a strong defense, they may request the lender to provide you with additional time to resolve the situation. 

However, if the judge determines that your response is insufficient to stop or delay the foreclosure proceedings, they will rule in favor of the lender. At this point, the lender can proceed with the foreclosure process. 

Foreclosure Sale and Deficiency Judgments

If the judge grants the lender the right to reclaim your home, a foreclosure sale will take place. Typically, this occurs within 30 to 45 days after the final judgment. At the foreclosure auction, the home will be sold, and you will be required to vacate the property. It’s important to note that junior lien holders may have the opportunity to purchase the property before the sale, up until the date of the foreclosure sale. In some cases, if you can provide evidence of payment before the foreclosure sale, usually around 10 days prior, you may still have a chance to retain ownership of your home.

In situations where the proceeds from the foreclosure sale are insufficient to cover the outstanding mortgage debt, the lender may opt to file another lawsuit against you. This lawsuit aims to obtain a deficiency judgment, which would require you to pay the remaining balance of the proceeds and the outstanding balance on the mortgage.

Getting the Help of a Skilled Foreclosure Lawyer in Florida

Understanding the concept of strategic foreclosure is crucial for homeowners in Florida facing the distressing prospect of foreclosure. A strategic foreclosure is a deliberate decision by a homeowner to default on their mortgage with a long-term plan in mind. By strategically walking away from an underwater mortgage, homeowners can minimize their financial losses and pave the way for a fresh start.

However, navigating the complexities of a strategic foreclosure can be a daunting task without professional guidance. A foreclosure attorney can evaluate the homeowner’s situation and help determine whether strategic foreclosure is the right option. They can analyze the homeowner’s financial circumstances, review the mortgage contract, and assess the potential legal consequences of strategic foreclosure.

At Charlip Law Group, our team of Florida foreclosure lawyers may be able to provide valuable support, answering questions, addressing concerns, and representing the homeowner’s rights in court, if necessary. Our experience and understanding of the legal system can be crucial in navigating the complexities of foreclosure proceedings. Contact us today at (305) 354-9313 to schedule a consultation.

Share With Friends
Contact Us

Tell us about your legal concern

Related Posts